Two Graphic Novel Adventures, Two Very Different Tables
Hold Up and Your Town sit side by side in the Graphic Novel Adventures line, but they ask you to do opposite things. One is a mature, backstabbing climb to the top; the other is a wild west town-building challenge. If you are choosing your first graphic novel adventure, the real question is not which is better—it is which one matches the people at your table.
The catalog descriptions give a clear enough picture to decide. Hold Up explicitly warns that it is for mature audiences only, while Your Town invites you to become a small-town mayor and manage its growth. That single contrast should drive your choice more than any mechanic.
What the catalog confirms about each book
- Hold Up: It is for mature audiences only. This is a hard gate for family game nights. If younger players are at the table, Hold Up is not the right pick.

Hold Up - Hold Up: You’ll try to go from the outhouse to the penthouse by robbing, tricking, or killing whoever you need to in order to make it to the top. The theme is openly ruthless and criminal. That tells you the tone before you open the cover.
- Your Town: You'll build buildings on a map to earn income, create jobs, attract new citizens, and gain a whole host of other benefits (and sometimes consequences) to help you manage the critical aspects of town! This is a management puzzle with visible growth and tradeoffs, not a crime story.

Your Town
Tone, audience, and what you actually do
Use this side-by-side to match each book to your group. The catalog does not provide player counts, play times, or age ranges beyond the mature-audience warning, so treat those as open questions to check on the box.
- Hold Up: Mature audiences only. You play a ruthless climb from outhouse to penthouse, using robbery, trickery, and killing. The appeal is the dark, competitive theme. Not suitable for kids or mixed-age family tables.
- Your Town: You are the mayor of a wild west small town. You build on a map to earn income, create jobs, attract citizens, and handle the benefits and consequences of growth. The appeal is management and planning rather than crime.
Which one should be your first graphic novel adventure?
Choose Hold Up first if your group is adults who enjoy dark humor, betrayal, and a clear criminal arc. The mature-audience warning is not decorative—it sets the whole experience. If you are playing with teenagers or a family group, skip it.
Choose Your Town first if you want a constructive, map-based challenge where progress comes from building and managing rather than robbing. It is the safer pick for beginners who want to see a town grow and do not mind juggling income, jobs, and citizens.
If you are buying for someone new to graphic novel adventures, Your Town is the more broadly approachable theme based on the supplied descriptions. Hold Up is better as a second or later purchase for a mature group that specifically wants a crime-driven story.
What the supplied information does not settle
The catalog records do not list player count, recommended age range, play time, or component lists for either book. They also do not describe how the graphic novel format works at the table. Those details may be on the box or in the rulebook, but they are not confirmed here.
That means you should not treat this comparison as a full review. It is a guide to tone and audience fit based on the publisher’s own descriptions. If you need exact setup or playtime, check the product page or the physical box before buying.



