The short answer: start with The Great Chase
If you want one clear recommendation, begin with Pirates: The Great Chase. The supplied catalog describes a self-contained hunt: you pick one of three pirates with different stats, then chase an escaped prisoner swimming toward a nearby island while watching for hidden objects along the way.
Pirates: City of Skulls is described as continuing where your adventure left off, exploring a pirate town and unlocking its secrets. That makes it the more natural second read rather than the entry point, because its premise assumes an adventure already in progress.
What each book actually asks you to do
- Pirates: The Great Chase: Choose one of three Pirates with a different set of stats, then find the prisoner who escaped your ship and is swimming toward a nearby island. A stat choice plus a clear objective gives a first-time reader a defined starting frame.

Pirates: The Great Chase - Pirates: The Great Chase: The book is described as a true treasure hunt where you keep your eyes peeled for hidden objects, and you never know what you will come across that could be helpful later. This tells you the reading activity is search-and-spot as much as decision-making, which suits readers who like scanning pages closely.
- Pirates: City of Skulls: You continue where your adventure left off and explore the bustling pirate town, trying to unlock its secrets and find what you are looking for. The continuation framing is the main reason to read this one second rather than first.

Pirates: City of Skulls
How the two pirate adventures differ
The catalog gives each book a different job. The Great Chase is a pursuit with a visible goal; City of Skulls is an exploration of a town with secrets to unlock. Neither description promises a specific number of pages, play time, or difficulty level, so treat those as open questions rather than deciding factors.
- Starting point: The Great Chase sets up its own chase and character choice. City of Skulls explicitly continues an adventure already underway.
- Core activity: The Great Chase leans on hidden-object searching during a pursuit. City of Skulls leans on exploring a pirate town and uncovering what it holds.
- Pacing feel: A chase with a swimming prisoner reads as forward motion. A bustling town reads as a place to poke around. The supplied information does not quantify either.
When City of Skulls is the better buy
If you have already read The Great Chase, or you specifically want the town-exploration side of pirate life, City of Skulls is the logical next purchase. Its premise is built on continuing an adventure, so it rewards a reader who already has a pirate storyline in motion.
If you are buying for someone else and are unsure whether they have started the series, The Great Chase is the safer gift because it does not depend on a prior book.
What the catalog confirms about each book
- Pirates: The Great Chase: Pirates: The Great Chase is listed at USD 14.71, with a catalog comparison price of USD 22.99. The lower listed price makes it an easier first purchase if you are testing whether the pirate branch suits you.
- Pirates: City of Skulls: Pirates: City of Skulls is listed at USD 14.94, with a catalog comparison price of USD 22.99. The two books sit close in price, so the reading order matters more than the cost difference.
A simple buying check before you choose
- Is this your first pirate Graphic Novel Adventure?: Choose The Great Chase. It gives you a character choice and a clear objective without requiring a previous book.
- Have you already read The Great Chase?: Choose City of Skulls. Its description is built around continuing where your adventure left off.
- Do you prefer searching pages for hidden objects?: The Great Chase explicitly asks you to keep your eyes peeled for hidden objects along the way.
- Do you prefer exploring a setting over chasing a target?: City of Skulls centers on a bustling pirate town and unlocking its secrets.
- Do you need a confirmed age range or component list?: The supplied records for these two books do not include an age range, component list, or play time. Check the product pages or packaging before buying for a young reader.
What the supplied information does not settle
The catalog does not state how long either book takes to read, how many endings or paths it contains, or whether the two pirate stories connect beyond the continuation framing in City of Skulls. It also does not list an age range or components for either title. If those details decide your purchase, confirm them on the product listing rather than assuming.
What the catalog does make clear is the intended order: The Great Chase establishes the chase, and City of Skulls continues the adventure in town. Buy The Great Chase first, then add City of Skulls when you want to keep the story going.



