Quick answer
Sherlock Holmes & Moriarty: Associates is a graphic novel adventure that continues the story from Four Investigations, now letting you play as Holmes, Watson, or even Moriarty. The box contains a full-color 80-page book with branching paths, character sheets, and a unique interrogation system.
What makes this different from a standard board game
Instead of a board, dice, or miniatures, this is a self-contained book. You read the story, make choices at decision points, and flip to the corresponding page. The only components are the book itself and a pencil to mark your choices—no setup or tear-down required.
The twist here is the ability to play as Moriarty. You get different interrogation options: as Holmes you rely on deduction and politeness; as Moriarty you can coerce and threaten suspects. This changes how you gather clues and which paths open up.
Trade-offs to consider before buying
If you prefer tactile components like cards, tokens, or miniatures, this book-only format might feel sparse. There are no expansions or add-ons—the entire experience is in one volume.
The story assumes you have played Sherlock Holmes: Four Investigations. While you can jump in here, you will miss character introductions and earlier plot threads. New players may want to start with the first book.
Decision rules: Should you buy?
- You love narrative-driven solo or co-op play: If you enjoy reading a mystery and making choices that affect the outcome, this is a perfect fit. No opponents, no timer—just the story.
- You want to replay a game with different outcomes: The Moriarty path changes interrogation options and story branches. Plan at least two playthroughs to see both sides. Mark your choices lightly so you can erase and replay later.
- You prefer traditional board game components: This is a book with no dice, cards, or miniatures. If you need physical pieces to feel engaged, look for a different product.
- You haven't played Sherlock Holmes: Four Investigations: The story directly continues from that book. You can start here, but you will miss context. Consider buying the first volume first. Check if the store offers a bundle with both books.
Product facts
- Sherlock Holmes & Moriarty: Associates: You can play as Holmes and Watson, or choose Moriarty who has joined the team under peculiar circumstances. Question suspects without fear of offending them, using coercion and threats to extract information. This gives the game high replay value—two playthroughs with different interrogation styles reveal different story branches and solutions.

Sherlock Holmes & Moriarty: Associates
Who is this for?
Best for
- Solo players who want a deep mystery without setup time
- Fans of Sherlock Holmes: Four Investigations looking for the next chapter
- Players who enjoy role-playing as the villain and using intimidation tactics
Not for
- Groups that prefer competitive or cooperative board games with physical components
- Players who want a standalone story without needing prior knowledge of the first book


