I’ve played through it twice already, once as Holmes and once as Watson, and the way each character’s clues lead to totally different outcomes keeps me coming back. The book’s pacing between cases is spot-on, and the ending genuinely surprised me.
Owen X.★★★★★
The branching paths actually change how each chapter plays out, so my second run through as Watson felt totally different from the first. It picks up nicely after the Four Investigations book, and the art holds up on every page.
Adam R.★★★★★
Playing as Moriarty this time completely flipped how I approached each case, and the branching choices actually made me second-guess my own deductions. It picks up right where the Four Investigations book left off, so start there first or you'll be a bit lost.